Culture and Attitude Play a Huge Role in Managing Credit and Other Risks
Original Post on CTRM Center: Culture and Attitude Play A Huge Role in Managing Credit and Other Risks – CTRM Center | CTRM Center
Author Dr. Gary M. Vasey
Having worked as an executive director for a proprietary trading firm for a period, I am only too aware of how good risk management intentions can be nullified by culture and attitude. Managing risk isn’t just about having processes in place, analytics and so on, it is about a top to bottom culture and that is often hard to instill and maintain – especially in good times. Last week, I had the pleasure of discussing this with Bill Quadrini, MD, Strategy and Innovation, CubeLogic, in some detail. His passion for credit risk is obvious and his background – working in and around credit risk with large and small customers over the last 20-years – has afforded him some remarkable insights. It’s all about incentives and culture at the end of the day, he told me. “Despite everything being so much more evolved now in terms of technologies and solutions, the human element always remains.”

As Bill points out, the last big crash was now 15-years ago. That means that some in the industry in positions of authority and management have never experienced what that is like. “Perhaps as much as one third to a half of the workforce have never seen a truly down market and they do not know how to prepare for it nor how to react if and when it reoccurs,” he told me. Not only that but many are still having issues dealing with the basics, he argues. “Things like how to get the right data to flow properly and in a timely manner into the right systems and which models are most appropriate to use.”
I was reminded of the old adage that ‘people do not know what it is they do not know’ that was drilled into me by an outside risk consultant back in my TransEnergy days listening to him and I know that he is absolutely correct in his assessment of industry preparedness. Bill also points to internal IT – once a cost center but now usually ran as a profit center, meaning that there are many restrictions on what it can and cannot do these days. “It has resulted in a suboptimal relationship between the business and IT internally,” he said.
Bill’s take is that the industry remains somewhat ill-prepared. A combination of inexperience, human nature and the nature of how business is often conducted means that being caught in surprise happens all too often – particularly with respect to credit risk. He points to a recent industry meeting he attended as evidence of this describing it as like walking back into 1985 as credit managers discussed issues like AR automation rather than focus on things like how to determine credit limits for counterparties and so on. He also points back to the 2014-17 period during which firms made lots of money during boom times only to see a ‘bloodbath’ in 2017 when firms cut capital investments, laid off staff and the industry saw massive defaults.
For Bill, the answer to this is to be an evangelist regarding credit risk. By using case studies, stories, warnings and so on to help people get into discussions about credit risk and solutions. He sees that the C-suite needs to provide leadership in this area and suggests one way to emphasize its importance is for them to set an explicit budget for credit loss that they are willing to accept. He points out that credit risk is an ‘in the weeds’ activity and that details matter very much and told me that good credit managers have a capacity to focus where making decisions really matters while automating elsewhere. “Cubelogic does all of this – data is all in one place, it is the system of record, it is rules-based and you can program your credit policies into the system and it displays neatly the information needed to make those decisions,” he said. In short, he sees Cubelogic as a key tool in the kitbag of credit managers but also recognizes that culture and openness remain key attributes in a credit risk focused entity.