Why Energy and Commodity Firms Need Specialist Credit Solutions

Credit and counterparty risk management has become an increasingly important aspect of commodity trading in recent years in which various sectors of the industry have often experienced liquidity or related issues resulting in bankruptcies and/or failures. Starting with the collapse of Enron and the US energy merchants almost 25-years ago, the emphasis on effective credit and counterparty risk has progressively increased. However, this has also posed a bit of an issue for firms who discovered quite quickly that their E/CTRM solution actually have quite limited credit risk capabilities. Many have resorted to using spreadsheets, homegrown solutions and/or commercially available credit solutions to supplement their E/CTRM for this specific purpose. Despite that, many still do stubbornly try to use a combination of an E/CTRM solution and some add-on spreadsheets to manage their credit exposure.

E/CTRM systems are designed for trading and market risk management, not credit—most don’t go very deep at all into credit functionality typically only handling limits and batch-level exposure monitoring. Most do not handle comprehensive credit limit setting, credit analysis, collateral management, and forecasting of future credit exposure across different exposure types. They also usually lack proper credit scoring models and require manual Excel-based processes to collect information and determine appropriate limits. As CubeLogic’s Ellen Stars told me, “even comprehensive E/CTRM solutions require multiple modules (credit, workflow, reporting) to actually provide complete credit functionality and that credit teams often end up less prioritized than front office needs in the implementation.”

Stand-alone credit systems actually cover a significant chunk of functionality. That will include comprehensive credit scoring capabilities and tools, exposure calculation and tracking against a variety of limits that can include different types of complex netting arrangements, sophisticated and specific analytical tools, collateral management across a broad range of collateral types and sometimes even KYC functions. It is very rare to find much, if any of this, in an E/CTRM. It is specialist territory and furthermore, integration is required across multiple systems to obtain the data it requires. Solutions like that offered by CubeLogic are “comprehensive and specific to credit and counterparty risk management,” she told me.

For example, E/CTRMs often lack comprehensive models for credit scoring—“organizations must manually collect financials, ratings agency data, and risk appetite information to determine limits,” CubeLogic’s Simon Dawes told me. “Credit scoring requires ingesting financial data across life cycles and ratings agency numbers to make informed limit decisions. Without dedicated credit systems, this process takes significant time and personnel using Excel-based workflows.” While many E/CTRM’s may have a field to capture a credit rating it usually has no real function and certainly doesn’t support recalculation when there is a rating change, for example.

Another area of complexity is collateral management – an area often not supported at all in E/CTRM solutions or to a limited degree. Beng able to handle complex collateral needs is a key requirement – various types of bank guarantees, lines of credit and increasingly, CSA’s. “Most tier-one traders have separate margining teams within credit departments due to the scale of managing daily margin calls across thousands of counterparties,” Ellen told me. “CSAs need to be able to handle different complexities including ratings-based rules, ISDA compliance for financial and physical power trading as well. Furthermore, liquidity price volatility increases the focus on cash collateral optimization and over-collateralization issues.”

Another area of omission in an E/CTRM is related to physical delivery according to Ellen and Simon. “Physical delivery creates unique credit risk evolution patterns not handled by E/CTRMs”, Ellen said. “Financial energy trades have MTM exposure and settlement exposure, while physical delivery involves gradual accrual settlement.” For companies delivering physical commodities, this is an extremely critical piece of functionality. E/CTRMs might provide rudimentary exposure calculations that simply show exposure presence then drop-off, missing the nuanced evolution across physical delivery phases meaning that again, specialised credit tools are needed to assess credit risk exposure evolution throughout the course of physical delivery.

E/CTRM’s just were not designed to provide comprehensive credit and counterparty risk analysis. As the importance of credit and liquidity has grown, so to has has the market for specialist credit solutions like that offered by CubeLogic. However, while once a specialist credit system may have been a luxury only top tier multi-jurisdictional firms could afford, it is increasingly becoming something almost all commodity exposed firms require.

Written by Gary Vasey on CTRM Center 

 

×