Are Energy and Commodities Firms Prepared for the Coming Credit Crisis?

By Dr. Gary M. Vasey, originally posted on CTRM Center

Periodically, I check in with Credit guru, Karl Sees of CubeLogic, for a catch up on what is going on in the world of credit.  In fact, we spoke just last week and the conversation rapidly focused on the current worrying landscape – Karl sees many systemic risks converging simultaneously across global economies and identified multiple warning signs of an impending event such as,

  • Credit priced to perfection similar to pre-2007/8
  • Covenant-light lending and payment-in-kind structures prevalent
  • Opaque financing through private credit markets
  • Hidden leverage exposed by Onset Financial’s nearly $2 billion off-balance-sheet exposure to First Brands
  • AI bubble parallels to telecoms boom/bust and vendor financing cycles.
CTRM Center for CTRM Software and ETRM Software
CubeLogic’s Karl Sees

In fact, almost every western nation is in debt – often significant, and unsustainable asset inflation is rampant. Karl noted potential scenarios including countries inflating their way out of debt, which would trigger policy shocks and spike interest rates and discussed crisis transmission risk with me: leverage built on leverage means market corrections force large funds to unwind positions, selling into falling markets and exacerbating the downturn, he said. It certainly looks very risky right now.

With so much occurring in global markets and so many warning signs, energy & commodity companies need to be carefully monitoring their exposure. However, these days, stress testing is key to trying to anticipate just what could go wrong and how it may impact portfolios. For Karl and CubeLogic however, there are other issues to consider around stress testing in order to be well prepared. Karl emphasized that transparency is the critical first layer of protection for firms preparing for crisis. “The initial objective of credit risk system projects is typically achieving push-button visibility into aggregated exposures across the portfolio,” he told me. “Stress testing requires covering fundamentals first to avoid false negatives or positives.” He described a common disaster scenario in which firms run stress tests showing that they would be fine given a specific event, but when that event actually happens in reality they are shocked to discover hidden portfolio risks that they missed. “The typical challenge is aggregating transactions and exposures across a “messy ETRM, CTRM spreadsheet landscape“, “ he said. “So, firms need to normalize data to view exposures down to transaction level and up to counterparty groups, industry sectors, and rating categories.” He argued that effective stress testing is only possible after mapping exposures and achieving full transparency.

Stress testing, he said, is definitely a key current driver for CubeLogic’s sales and clients are actively buying this capability but he emphasized that stress testing is most effective only after achieving transparency across the full portfolio

Karl is also concerned by what he described as the triangular interrelationship between liquidity, credit, and market risk, which are very hard to stress test. For example, a counterparty misses a margin call under a CSA and defaults creating ripple effects across multiple exposed counterparties. When a large hedging counterparty defaults, what appeared to be collaterallized credit risk suddenly becomes uncovered market exposure and if the market moves the wrong way after the counterparty default, firms face market risk they never knew they had. He described these interconnected risks as “probably the next frontier” in industry risk management noting that “some firms are starting to address interconnected risks and doing it well, but it’s still an emerging capability.”

Of course, these concerns are driving demand for credit solutions like those offered by CubeLogic and Karl pointed to six recent go-lives with customers by CubeLogic and strong recent growth of the vendor as evidence that mature firms are investing to protect themselves. However, Karl remains surprised that “demand isn’t even stronger given the risk environment and size of energy/commodity markets. Are firms investing internally and quietly, or simply not preparing adequately?” he asked. He thinks that “actually not nearly enough energy and commodity companies are taking preparation seriously,” while worrying that many firms mistakenly believe financial market instability is outside their sector and therefore not relevant to them.

 

×