CFTC and FERC in Flux: Energy and Commodity Traders Should Not Take Their Eyes Off the Ball
By most measures, 2025 has been an exceptionally tumultuous year for both the US Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). On the one hand, we have seen a sudden and dramatic change in energy policy under the second Trump administration, and on the other hand we have witnessed an unprecedented change at the leadership levels at both the CFTC and FERC. What does this upheaval mean for energy and commodity traders in the US market from a regulatory compliance perspective, and how should firms respond to such an extraordinary period of change? Read on to find out.
All change at the CFTC and FERC – then change again..
To say that the US energy and commodity trading regulators have gone through an unprecedented chapter of change in 2025 is a huge understatement. But what caused this? In short – politics. Commissioners at both the FERC and the CFTC are appointed along political lines. The party occupying the White House also drives the agendas at each agency by appointing a majority of Commissioners (both agencies have five Commissioners each when fully stocked, with the ruling party typically appointing three). Crucially, they also get to appoint the Chair. While this may appear to be a routine administrative detail, it is highly significant for energy and commodity trading firms. Changes in leadership often directly influence the sector — particularly an agency’s appetite for, and approach to, monitoring and enforcing market conduct. Some taking an aggressive line, with others a more lenient and business friendly stance.
With this in mind, welcome to 2025… On the 20th of January at the start of the second Trump administration, Democrat-appointed Rostin Behnam stepped down as Chair of the CFTC [1]. His temporary replacement was Caroline Pham [2], a Republican-appointed Commissioner who had served as a CFTC Commissioner since 2022. A permanent replacement was also nominated at around the same time, namely former Commissioner Brian Quintenz. Since then, all the remaining Commissioners have either stepped down voluntarily or reached the end of their natural five year terms with no replacements forthcoming from either side of the aisle. The confirmation of Quintenz as permanent Chair was also abruptly cancelled in late July leaving Acting Chair Pham in limbo. Upon the departure of Commissioner Kristian Johnson on 3 September [3], the agency was left in an unprecedented position of being a “Commission of one” with only the Acting Chair left in seat. With no minimum mandated quorum to function, and no replacements being proposed, speculation was rife regarding a potential merger between the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the US federal financial regulator (although this has since been denied from several quarters including by the current Chair of the SEC [4]).
Adding to the turmoil at the leadership level, there were also notable movements at the Divisional level. Brian Young, the head of the Division of Enforcement (DOE) left the CFTC in June 2025 having only been appointed to the role in February [5]. While he has since been ably replaced, the timing and manner of his departure raised some eyebrows (he took voluntary redundancy under the Department of Government Efficiency – or DOGE – the Trump administration’s now-infamous cost cutting programme).
FERC was not immune from the change. 2025 has seen the federal agency cycle through four Chairs coupled with several new replacement-Commissioners, and not all without controversy. The year started with Democrat-appointed Chair Willie Phillips at the helm. Like his CFTC counterpart, he stepped down in January at the start of the second Trump administration, then leaving the Commission in April. He was replaced as Chair by the Republican-appointed Mark Christie who had served as a FERC Commissioner since 2021. Christie’s tenure was short-lived however, abruptly announcing his departure from the Commission in August. In a surprise to many, David Rosner, a Democrat-appointee, was named as Christie’s replacement [6] in a rare, but ultimately brief, display of bipartisanship. In the context of the five-seat Commission, at this point the number of sitting Commissioners were also reduced to three – rapidly heading in the same direction as the CFTC.
Fast-forward to October 2025, and the US Senate finally confirmed the appointment of two new Republican-aligned Commissioners [7] bringing FERC back to a full complement of five. While Commissioner Laura Swett had served for several years at FERC in a variety of roles, including as a lead attorney in the Office of Enforcement, her co-appointee David LaCerte joined with very little experience in the energy industry making his appointment controversial in some quarters. Despite this, many were optimistic that the fully restored Commission would see a period of much needed stability at the top. Alas, it was not to last. Later in October Rosner was summarily removed as Chair with Laura Swett assuming the role [8] being the third Chair appointment in 2025, and the fourth to assume the role within the calendar year. An unprecedented situation for any period.
Leadership versus Operations – the show must go on
While the turmoil at both agencies at the leadership level over the last year has been extraordinary, has it had a marked impact from the perspective of firms trading energy and commodities in the US? That is to say – has the “churn in Chairs” at FERC and the “Commission of one” at the CFTC caused a notable change in the day to day enforcement activities by either agency? While it is not possible to assess their inner workings, there is sufficient evidence in the public domain to suggest that the show largely goes on.
While Acting Chair Pham has pushed for the CFTC to clean up its approach to enforcement by stopping what she deemed to be “regulation by enforcement” [9], this has certainly not meant an end to enforcement altogether. With many examples of enforcement cases being published throughout the year [10] [11], Pham also announced an “Enforcement Sprint” [12] to help accelerate the resolution of open cases involving non-egregious infringements. This initiative resulted in over USD 8 million in fines. In August, the CFTC announced [13] that it had – for the first time – acquired a commercially-developed transaction surveillance capability. The new tool will replace its 1990s-era analytics tool and is almost certain to trigger a major increase in Requests for Information (RFI) and significantly increase its capacity to detect and penalise illicit behaviour.
So, while it may be tempting to assume that a Republican-led Commission is likely to adopt a more “business-friendly” stance – that is less regulation and less enforcement – the developments above suggest that the prospect of enforcement is far from being off the table.
A similar sentiment may also be extended to FERC. While a Republican-appointed Chair is now at the helm, Laura Swett comes from an enforcement background having personally pursued cases as a lead attorney for FERC. While Swett will undoubtedly be saddled with several key priorities of the new administration (such as establishing new rules to accelerate the interconnection of large loads for data centres [14]), she hardly fits the mould of a benevolent, business friendly head of the agency. As for the CFTC, FERC has pursued several high-profile cases including for cross-market manipulation [15] over the year. In its recently published 2025 Report on Enforcement [16], FERC highlighted its top priority as being the enforcement of fraud and market manipulation. In total, the agency resolved 11 cases with settlements totalling USD 36.57 million over the financial year.
The report also highlights than in 2025, the Division of Analytics and Surveillance continued monitoring for potential market manipulation and other anomalous activities in the market producing approximately 1,780 surveillance alerts for gas trading and 1,920 surveillance reviews for power trading. These alerts yielded dozens of in-depth investigations, resulting in referrals to the Divisions of Investigations (DOI). Again, hardly the actions of a benevolent agency.
Aside from the CFTC and FERC, US exchanges continue to be enthusiastic enforcers across traded energy and commodity markets. In their quasi-regulatory role, exchanges like the CME and ICE Futures US frequently penalise behaviour such as wash trading, spoofing, pre-arranged trading and position limit violations. This “second order” of regulatory oversight provides a compelling case for firms to actively monitor their behaviour on such venues regardless of the prevailing mood set by the Federal agencies.
What should energy and commodity trading firms do under these circumstances?
Considering the uncertainty described above characterising much of 2025, how should energy and commodity trading firms respond? Should firms buy into the fashionable narratives that leadership turmoil means less chance of enforcement or that a business-friendly regulator is less likely to enforce? After all, it may be logical to conclude that the turmoil at the leadership level at the CFTC and FERC means a commensurate reduction in the risk of enforcement for illicit market behaviour. Firms that make that assumption do so at their peril.
Instead, we suggest firms take a more balanced and prudent view and consider the actions below.
Maintain surveillance across venues and products and tighten them up in some areas such as algorithmic (“algo”) trading. Make sure you have robust trade, order, and position surveillance covering both physical and financial markets, with regular calibration. This is as much for handling RFIs from the exchanges as it is from the federal regulators. Areas of higher-risk trading (such as algo trading) warrant a specific focus.
Ensure clear and robust controls are placed around new strategies and algos. Requiring formal approvals, documented rationales, and pre-implementation testing for new trading strategies or algos, including parameter changes, with sign-off from front office, risk, and compliance. This is baseline good-practice and should be maintained regardless of the regulatory winds.
Maintain governance and escalation paths. Having a structured market conduct governance forum that reviews surveillance MI, enforcement trends, and high-risk activities is fundamental to trading governance regardless of enforcement risk. Having clear escalation routes for RFIs from regulators and exchanges are also fundamental – and will potentially be in high demand once the CFTC’s new surveillance capability is fully operational.
Continued investment in people and training. Some firms may be tempted to scale back their compliance spend during this period, potentially falling into a complacency trap. Instead, firms should continue investing in this area, with modest annual increases as a bare minimum as well as maintaining staff development and training initiatives.
Run periodic health checks on systems and controls. Prepare for the worst, hope for the best. Firms should continue to review their internal controls, including their surveillance tools and position limit management frameworks to ensure that they work as designed, and continue to be properly documented. These should always reflect current trading activities of the firm and external enforcement priorities – even if the external environment appears to be relatively benign in the present.
Conclusion
In practical terms, the turmoil of 2025 at FERC and the CFTC should not lull energy and commodity trading firms into relaxing their guard: leadership may be volatile, but surveillance and enforcement risks are not going away. Despite empty seats and changing Chairs, the CFTC has continued to bring cases and invest in a modern surveillance system that will make it easier to spot problematic trading. FERC, led by a Chair with a strong enforcement background, has kept fraud and market manipulation at the top of its agenda and has maintained an impressive level of monitoring and investigations despite the many leadership changes.
Layer on top of this the steady drumbeat of disciplinary action from exchanges such as CME and ICE, and it becomes reasonably clear that the risk of regulatory scrutiny is alive and well. Firms that treat this period as an opportunity to trim surveillance, relax trading controls, weaken governance, or cut compliance budgets are effectively betting that they will avoid attention from better equipped regulators and ever-active exchanges.
A more prudent course is to maintain and, where needed, tighten surveillance coverage, approvals, governance, training, and periodic health checks, on the assumption that RFIs and investigations will continue regardless of who occupies the Chair. The federal regulatory agencies may be in flux, but firms that act as if enforcement risk is constant will be far better prepared for whatever comes next.
Footnotes:
[1] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/SpeechesTestimony/behnamstatement010725
[2] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9035-25
[3] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/SpeechesTestimony/opajohnson24
[4] https://www.sec.gov/newsroom/speeches-statements/atkins-092925-harmonization-new-era-collaboration-between-sec-cftc
[5] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9053-25
[6] https://ferc.gov/news-events/news/president-trump-names-david-rosner-chairman-ferc
[7] https://www.ferc.gov/news-events/news/senate-confirms-swett-lacerte-ferc
[8] https://www.ferc.gov/news-events/news/president-trump-names-laura-swett-chairman-ferc
[9] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9044-25
[10] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9125-25
[11] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9118-25
[12] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9114-25
[13] https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/9110-25
[14] https://www.energy.gov/articles/secretary-wright-acts-unleash-american-industry-and-innovation-newly-proposed-rules
[15] https://cms.ferc.gov/media/20250613-191ferc61200-in25-2-000-green-plains-settlement-agreement
[16] https://www.ferc.gov/news-events/news/fy2025-report-enforcement