Why Credit Risk Is Moving Up the Agenda in Commodity Trading

by Gary Vasey, CTRM Center

It’s always interesting to talk with people who have been in the industry for some time, particularly when their career has encompassed a number of roles or experience with different vendors. Simon Dawes is a good example, having been active in the industry since the mid-1990s with a particular emphasis on the credit risk space. These days, Simon is with CubeLogic, and it was there that I caught up with him for a conversation about the industry, credit risk, and CubeLogic. Having known Simon for many years, I must confess that we also spent some time reminiscing.

The dedicated credit risk vendor market has always been somewhat niche — essentially a single mid-office function — and has never been particularly crowded,” Simon told me. Vendors offering credit solutions specifically into the commodities space first emerged immediately after the Enron-led US merchant energy collapse. The two main platforms that emerged at that time were Raft (which later became Energy Credit, then Brady Credit Risk) and Rome (acquired by Triple Point/ION). Today, however, “the European, MEAR and APAC credit risk vendor market has narrowed to essentially two dedicated players including CubeLogic. In the US, there are a couple more players,” he explained.

Beyond these vendors, credit functionality has often been handled through internal development. “Companies either rely on their E/CTRM’s built-in credit capabilities for less complex needs or build in-house systems,” Simon said. In fact, I have seen this directly, having once worked for a European power trader that had developed a comprehensive internal credit solution.

Credit risk has always been something of an odd space in that respect — a small number of vendors alongside a wide range of homegrown solutions, often rudimentary, or reliance on CTRM credit functionality. “Credit risk has historically been treated as an afterthought — companies implement an E/CTRM, find the credit functionality insufficient, and then bolt on workarounds,” Simon noted. Periodically, market events refocus attention on the need for better credit solutions, and the current geopolitical volatility is a good example.

Such events inevitably sharpen the focus on credit: repricing, counterparty rating downgrades, limit breaches, and margin call visibility quickly become urgent priorities. At the same time, regulatory mandates around KYC and sanctions screening are driving greater scrutiny of counterparties and creating additional demand for dedicated credit solutions. “Credit policy increasingly requires it, and sanctions screening is now a key component alongside traditional rating inputs such as S&P or Moody’s,” Simon said. Growing complexity is another driver, particularly the increased use of Credit Support Agreements (CSAs), which require greater calculation rigor. “CSAs have become the standard collateral underpinning, with bank guarantees less common and collateral itself harder to obtain,” he added.

For Simon, CubeLogic has a clear set of differentiators in the credit software market. He describes it as a 240-person company, founded in 2009, that is entirely focused on risk, with roughly two-thirds of the organization dedicated to credit risk. Historically, CubeLogic has supported firms operating at the highest levels of scale and complexity, but Simon believes the rest of the market and gravitating toward vendors whose products have been shaped by the demanding requirements of leading market participants.

He was also quick to point out that CubeLogic is not in the CTRM business — it is focused purely on risk, with deep expertise in credit and other forms of commodity risk management. The company is not engaged in CTRM cross-selling but is instead focused on delivering best-of-breed credit and risk solutions. “The net effect of that focus and expertise is a best-of-breed product, a well-defined roadmap, and strong investment in innovation,” he said. “Functionally, the product is deep and rich, built on years of input from market-leading commodity firms, and customers benefit from continued investment in new technologies and expanded capabilities on the roadmap.”

×